Before each retention vote, the Utah Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission surveys the lawyers and court staff who appear before each judge, sends trained observers into courtrooms and publishes what it finds. Every judge below meets or exceeds the commission's standards.
All 16 judges on city ballots met the state's performance standards
Published
How does the state grade a judge, and what did lawyers and observers say?
Near the bottom of your ballot is a run of yes or no questions that are easy to skip: should this judge stay on the bench? Utah judges are appointed first and face voters later.
- Utah Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission, Know Your Judges (2026 evaluations for all 16 judges listed) (retrieved 2026-10-18)
- 2026 Utah Voter Information Pamphlet
- Utah Senate Journal, 2022 Second Extraordinary Session (Pohlman 25 to 0)
- Utah Legislature Senate Judicial Confirmation Committee record (Stormont, 2023)
- Utah Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission, 2026 Evaluation Overview pages (retrieved Oct 16, 2026) (retrieved 2026-10-16)
- Hideout v. Summit County, Utah Supreme Court, 2024 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Bingham v. Gourley, Utah Supreme Court, 2024 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Andrus, Utah Supreme Court, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- In re P.M., Utah Court of Appeals, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Beames, Utah Court of Appeals, 2022 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Nunes, Utah Court of Appeals, 2020 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Al-Imari v. UDOT, Utah Court of Appeals, 2026 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Northern Monticello Alliance v. San Juan County, Utah Court of Appeals, 2023 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Scott, Utah Court of Appeals, 2022 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Bridgewaters, Utah Court of Appeals, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Wahlstrom, Utah Court of Appeals, 2026 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Vargas, Utah Court of Appeals, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Farm Bureau v. Weston, Utah Court of Appeals, 2023 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Farm Bureau v. Weston, Utah Court of Appeals, 2023 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Walmart v. Tax Commission, Utah Court of Appeals, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Ramirez v. Hon. Landau, Utah Court of Appeals, 2026 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Mitton, Utah Court of Appeals, 2024 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Mitton, Utah Court of Appeals, 2024 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Griffin v. Snow Christensen and Martineau, Utah Court of Appeals, 2023 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Griffin v. Snow Christensen and Martineau, Utah Court of Appeals, 2023 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Gallegos v. Brewski's, Utah Court of Appeals, 2026, a Second District case from Ogden (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Sorbonne, Utah Court of Appeals, 2020 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Miller, Utah Court of Appeals, 2019 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Anderson v. Hon. Bates and McCaffrey v. Anderson, Utah Supreme Court, 2025 and 2026 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Anderson v. Hon. Bates and McCaffrey v. Anderson, Utah Supreme Court, 2025 and 2026 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Menzies, Utah Supreme Court, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Menzies, Utah Supreme Court, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Peng v. Meeks, Utah Supreme Court, 2024 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Jennings, Utah Supreme Court, 2026 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Armenta v. Unified Fire, Utah Supreme Court, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Connelley, Utah Court of Appeals, 2026 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Clara, Utah Supreme Court, 2024 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- Raser Technologies v. Morgan Stanley, Utah Supreme Court, 2019 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- State v. Debrok, Utah Supreme Court, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- In re E.M., Utah Supreme Court, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- In re I.C., Utah Court of Appeals, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- In re E.D., Utah Court of Appeals, 2026 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- In re D.A.M.G., Utah Court of Appeals, 2023 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- In re P.M., Utah Court of Appeals, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)
- In re I.C., Utah Court of Appeals, 2025 (retrieved 2026-10-17)